Your cart

Your cart is empty

Check out these collections.

Best Selling

Cat Toys

21 Results

Clear filters
Kitty Cocktails 2 plush catnip toys in orange and green cocktail shapes with colorful feathers
Kitty Cocktails organic catnip toys, 2-piece Dapper set with brown wood-pattern packaging and bright green feather
Sold out

Kitty Cocktails (2 Cocktails) Organic Catnip Toys

$13.00

Catch a Meowse Dapper cat toy, two grey and black plush mice
Sold out

Catch a Meowse

$10.00

Owls - Set of 2 plush cat toys in plaid brown/black fabric.

Owls - Set of 2

$10.00

Purrona Bottle & Ball organic catnip toys, 2-piece set with orange bottle and yellow/blue ball
Purrona Bottle & Ball organic catnip toys set, 2 pieces: orange bottle and multicolor ball.

Purrona (Bottle & Ball) Organic Catnip Toys

$13.00

Kitty Clicquot bottle and caviar catnip toy set - 2 toys: green champagne-bottle plush and blue round toy
Kitty Clicquot Bottle & Caviar Organic Catnip cat toy in brown wood‑grain packaging with blue and yellow feathers

Kitty Clicquot (Bottle & Caviar) Organic Catnip

$13.00

Snuggly Cup 3-Pack Catnip Toys - plush cups in pink, teal, and cream
Sold out

Snuggly Cup 3-Pack Organic Catnip Toys

$13.00

Feline Frenzy Tutti FUR-utti plush cat toy set: two fruit slices, banana and watermelon

Feline Frenzy - Tutti FUR-utti

$10.00

Kitty Vuiton Balls catnip toy set of 3 - plush balls with monogram patterns in assorted colors
Kitty Vuiton Balls Monogram Organic Catnip Toys in brown wood-grain packaging

Kitty Vuiton Balls (Monogram) Organic Catnip Toys

$13.00

Pair of White Paw Mango & Lime organic catnip toys; plush white bottles with orange/green trim and feather accents.
White Paw Mango & Lime catnip toys set of 2, plush rollers with orange/green accents and feathers

White Paw (Mango & Lime) Organic Catnip Toys

$13.00

Meowbucks coffee cup catnip toys (2), white and tan plush cups with organic catnip
Meowbucks coffee cup catnip toys (2) - organic catnip-filled, machine washable.
Sold out

Meowbucks (2 Coffee Cups) Organic Catnip Toys

$13.00

Kitty Vuiton Balls Checker organic catnip toys, 3-pack in black, white, and brown checker fabrics
Kitty Vuiton Balls checker organic catnip toys by Haute Diggity Dog, Dapper collection

Kitty Vuiton Balls (Checker) Organic Catnip Toys

$13.00

Octopus Cat Teaser Wand with six colorful plush octopuses on a wooden wand
Octopus cat teaser wand, purple plush with blue eyes on a wooden stick
Sold out

Moo - Octopus Cat Teaser Wand

$10.00

3 colors
  • Purple
  • Green
  • Pink
Dapper Bandit Buddies plush set of two: raccoon and fox characters with plaid and cream faces
Bandit Buddies two plush crinkle cat toys: raccoon with houndstooth pattern and mask, fox with cream face and brown ears

Feline Frenzy Forest Friends - Bandit Buddies

$10.00

2-piece Cats Blue Ribbon Dapper cat toy set with blue and red labels and feather accents

Cats Blue Ribbon by Haute Diggity Kitty

$13.00

Kitty Bowl ornament in glossy red glass with white interior, paw prints and cat silhouettes.
Kitty Bowl Ornament, red round glass holiday ornament with white paw prints and white center bowl

Kitty Bowl Ornament

$17.99

Candy-shaped cat toy balls in bright spiral colors with ribbons and feathers
Candy-shaped cat toy in purple and orange with a spiral core and feathered tails.
Sale

Moo - Candy-Shaped Cat Toy

$7.00 $1.75

2 colors
  • Purple
  • Green
Tassel Wand Cat Toy set of 3 pastel pom-pom wands with glitter star wings
Tassel Wand Cat Toy with pastel beads and iridescent fringe
Sold out

Moo - Tassel Wand Cat Toy

$10.00

3 colors
  • Purple
  • Blue
  • Pink
Moo canned cat toy set of 3 red cans with colorful labels.
Moo canned cat toy, red can with bright yellow chili sauce label
Sold out

Moo - Canned Cat Toy

$8.00 $2.00

3 colors
  • Chili
  • Peanut
  • Tomato
Feline Frenzy Kitty-Boom toy set: two plush bombs, black with red pom-pom and yellow stem, red TNT plush.
Feline Frenzy Kitty-Boom toy set: two plush crinkle toys with colorful pom-poms and an organic catnip sticker
Sold out

Feline Frenzy Kitty-Boom Toy Set

$10.00

Watermelon-themed cat scratcher mat with crocheted red center and green rind
Cauli Watermelon Cat Scratcher Mat, round watermelon-pattern mat with red center and green rind, cat scratching.
Sold out

Cauli - Watermelon Cat Scratcher Mat

$18.00 $10.80

Kitty Cowboy Dapper cat toy, brown suede boot duo with yellow Lets Get Rowdy lettering, 2-pack

Kitty Cowboy by Haute Diggity Kitty

$13.00